Why Trump’s Arlington Debacle Is So Serious
The former president violated one of America’s most sacred places.
This article was featured in the One Story to Read Today newsletter. Sign up for it here.
The
section of Arlington National Cemetery that Donald Trump visited on
Monday is both the liveliest and the most achingly sad part of the grand
military graveyard, set aside for veterans of the wars in Iraq and
Afghanistan. In Section 60, young widows can be seen using clippers and
scissors to groom the grass around their husbands’ tombstones as lots of
children run about.
Karen
Meredith knows the saddest acre in America only too well. The
California resident’s son, First Lieutenant Kenneth Ballard, was the
fourth generation of her family to serve as an Army officer. He was
killed in Najaf, Iraq, in 2004, and laid to rest in Section 60. She puts
flowers on his gravesite every Memorial Day. “It’s not a number, not a
headstone,” she told me. “He was my only child.”
The
sections of Arlington holding Civil War and World War I dead have a
lonely and austere beauty. Not Section 60, where the atmosphere is
sanctified but not somber—too many kids, Meredith recalled from her
visits to her son’s burial site. “We laugh, we pop champagne. I have met
men who served under him, and they speak of him with such respect. And
to think that this man”—she was referring to Trump—“came here and put
his thumb up—”
She fell silent for a moment on the telephone, taking a gulp of air. “I’m trying not to cry.”
For
Trump, defiling what is sacred in our civic culture borders on a
pastime. Peacefully transferring power to the next president, treating
political adversaries with at least rudimentary grace, honoring those
soldiers wounded and disfigured in service of our country—Trump long ago
walked roughshod over all these norms. Before he tried to overturn a
national election, he mocked his opponents in the crudest terms and
demeaned dead soldiers as “suckers.”
Read: Trump calls Americans killed in war “suckers” and “losers”
But
the former president outdid himself this week, when he attended a
wreath-laying ceremony honoring 13 American soldiers killed in a suicide
bombing in Kabul during the final havoc-marked hours of the American
withdrawal. Trump laid three wreaths and put hand over heart; that is a
time-honored privilege of presidents. Trump, as is his wont, went
further. He walked to a burial site in Section 60 and posed with the
family of a fallen soldier, grinning broadly and giving a thumbs-up for his campaign photographer and videographer.
Few
spaces in the United States join the sacred and the secular to more
moving effect than Arlington National Cemetery, 624 acres set on a bluff
overlooking the Potomac River and our nation’s capital. More than 400,000 veterans and their dependents have been laid to rest here, among them nearly 400 Medal of Honor recipients. Rows of matching white tombstones stretch to the end of sight.
A cemetery employee politely attempted
to stop the campaign staff from filming in Section 60. Taking campaign
photos and videos at gravesites is expressly forbidden under federal
law. The Trump entourage, according to a subsequent statement by the
U.S. Army, which oversees the cemetery, “abruptly pushed” her aside.
Trump’s campaign soon posted a video on TikTok,
overlaid with Trump’s narration: “We didn’t lose one person in 18
months. And then they”—the Biden administration—“took over, that
disaster of leaving Afghanistan.”
Trump was unsurprisingly not telling the truth; 11 soldiers
were killed in Afghanistan in his last year in office, and his
administration had itself negotiated the withdrawal. But such
fabrications are incidental sins compared with what came next. A top
Trump adviser, Chris LaCivita, and campaign spokesperson Steven Cheung
talked to reporters and savaged the employee who had tried to stop the
entourage. Cheung referred to her as “an unnamed individual, clearly
suffering a mental-health episode.” LaCivita declared her a “despicable
individual” who ought to be fired.
There was, of course, another way to handle this mistake. Governor Spencer Cox of Utah had accompanied Trump
to the cemetery, and his campaign emailed out photos of the governor
and the former president there. When challenged, Cox did what is foreign
to Trump: He apologized.
“You are correct,” Cox replied to a person criticizing the event on X,
adding, “It did not go through the proper channels and should not have
been sent. My campaign will be sending out an apology.”
Read: Trump dishonors fallen soldiers again
This
was not a judgment call, or a minor violation of obscure bureaucratic
boilerplate. In the regulations governing visitors and behavior at
Arlington National Cemetery, many paragraphs lay out what behavior is
acceptable and what is not. These read not as suggestions but as
commandments. Memorial services are intended to honor the fallen, the
regulations note, with a rough eloquence: “Partisan activities are
inappropriate in Arlington National Cemetery, due to its role as a
shrine to all the honored dead of the Armed Forces of the United States
and out of respect for the men and women buried there and for their
families.”
As
the clamor of revulsion swelled this week, LaCivita did not back off.
On Wednesday, the Trump adviser posted a photo of Trump at Arlington
Cemetery on X and added these words:
“The Photo that shook the world and reminded America who the real
Commander in Chief is …August 26th 2024 ..Mark the day @KamalaHarris
and weak @JoeBiden.”
The Army, which is historically loath to enter politics, issued a rare statement yesterday
rebuking the Trump campaign, noting that ceremony participants “had
been made aware” of relevant federal laws “prohibiting political
activities” and that the employee “acted with professionalism.” The Army
said it “considers this matter closed” because the cemetery employee
had declined to press charges.
Meanwhile, an unrepentant Trump team kept stoking the controversy. Yesterday, LaCivita posted another photo of Trump at Arlington and added this: “Reposting this hoping to trigger the hacks at @SecArmy”—the Army secretary’s office.
It
had the quality of middle-school graffiti, suggesting that Trump viewed
the controversy as yet another chance to mock his critics before moving
on to the next outrage. For grieving families with loved ones buried in
Section 60, moving on is not so easy.
How
old, I asked Meredith, was your son at the time of his death? “He was
26,” she replied. “He did not have time to live. I didn’t get to dance
at his wedding. I didn’t get to play with grandkids.”
This
week, all she could do was call out a crude and self-regarding
78-year-old man for failing, in that most sacred of American places, to
comport himself with even the roughest facsimile of dignity.